If you are looking for the best Italian restaurants in Little Italy, you’ve come to the right place. Once the densely packed haven for Italian immigrants, Little Italy has been in existence since the 1870s. Formerly filled with thousands of immigrants who lived in tenements, this area was never meant to be lavish or overly exquisite. Rather, Little Italy was designed to be a home away from home for those who came to America seeking better lives for themselves and their families. Indeed, an area that was created as a means of providing people with all things authentically Italian, much like in the 1870s, today one of the top reasons people travel to Little Italy is for the authentically Italian cuisine. Coming from a nation known for its savory sauces and other tasty treats, Italian food is amongst some of the favorite foods in the country. That said, are you traveling to Little Italy sometime soon and need suggestions for places to eat?
Best Restaurants in Little Italy:
1. Angelo’s of Mulberry Street
Located on 146 Mulberry Street, Angelo’s has been in existence since 1902. A legendary restaurant offering authentic Southern Italian cuisine, Angelo’s has prided itself on consistently providing their customers with a superior dining experience from the very beginning. Offering an award-winning menu filled with everything from cold cuts to calamari, you’ll go for the experience and stay for the food
Furthermore, a variety of fine wines and other top-shelf alcoholic drinks is one of the top reasons people love dining in Little Italy, and at Angelo’s in particular. Serving everything from Cristal to Dom Perignon, Pinot Grigio, and more, the wine and drink selection only adds to your eating experience. Additionally offering an array of daily specials, customers have the option to choose from a variety of specially priced delectable foods almost every day of the week.
2. Paesanos of Little Italy
Located on 136 Mulberry Street, for those who wish to try a variety of cuisines in Little Italy, this restaurant is for you. Open daily for lunch and dinner, no matter if you are looking for a light appetizer or a full meal, Paesanos has you covered. A place that is purportedly the epitome of Italian charm, although the food is one of the main attractions of this restaurant, the authentically Italian vibe is also one of the reasons people love to eat here. Serving a wide variety of old-world Italian meals, which are created using authentic methods and with the freshest ingredients, the taste of their foods is as realistic as the atmosphere itself. Offering everything from stuffed artichokes to an array of pasta dishes, no matter what type of Italian food you’re looking for, you will likely find something perfect for your taste buds at Paesanos.
3. Da Gennaro Restaurant
Located on 129 Mulberry Street, Da Gennaro boasts about being the best dining experience outside of your own grandmother’s kitchen. Located right smack dab in the heart of Little Italy, this restaurant is conveniently located near the other eateries on this list as well as many others. Decorated with vintage rustic Italian décor, the vibe of this place, like various others in the area, is one that can only be described as authentically Italian. Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner every single day, the menu also includes an array of foods great for all day, brunch, or dessert. Moreover, they offer a variety of both alcoholic and non-alcoholic drinks, and an area for special events and private dining.
4. Da Nico Ristorante
Located on 64 Mulberry Street, Da Nico has been a family-owned and -operated business since 1993. Now considered a staple within Little Italy, this now infamous eatery has served the likes of the New York Yankees and former mayor Giuliani, among many others. Offering a wide variety of authentic Italian dishes, no matter if you want a plate of pasta or a pizza made in their authentic coal fire over, the meals at Da Nico are as filling as they are satisfying. Priding themselves on serving only “the freshest, high-quality Italian cuisine,” customers not only rave about the food, but the excellent service and authentically Italian ambiance to boot.
5. Capri Ristorante
Located on145-147 Mulberry Street, Capri Ristorante is right in the heart of Little Italy. Although it has only been open since 2016, this restaurant has received rave reviews from the very beginning. A favorite among locals, critics, and visitors, Capri Ristorante has a retro 1960s feel that everyone who visits seems to love. No matter if you are craving a light snack or a full meal, Capri Ristorante has you covered. With the help of award-winning Italian chef, Franco Aliberti, they offer many seafood-centered meals as well as many other delectable dishes.
Overall, finding the best Italian restaurants in Little Italy is much easier than you think. By starting with this list, you are well on your way to tasting a wide array of foods that are authentically Italian and made right here in the U.S.